Steve Wynn, the Las Vegas casino billionaire, is the man who accidentally ripped a hole in his Picasso, Le Rêve, valued at $139 million. The incident happened in 2006 when Wynn struck the canvas with his elbow while gesturing during a conversation with friends. This momentary slip became one of the most famous accidents in art history, leading to a costly restoration and a surprising rise in the painting’s eventual sale price.
The accident in the gallery
The painting, created by Pablo Picasso in 1932, depicted his then-mistress Marie-Thérèse Walter. Wynn had just agreed to sell the work to hedge fund manager Steven A. Cohen for $139 million. During a viewing party attended by high-profile guests, including screenwriter Nora Ephron, Wynn was explaining the history of the piece. He suffered from retinitis pigmentosa, a degenerative eye disease that severely limits peripheral vision. While gesturing enthusiastically, he did not see how close his arm was to the canvas. His elbow hit the artwork, creating a six-inch vertical tear.
Immediate consequences and restoration
The sale to Cohen was immediately cancelled. Wynn faced the prospect of repairing a masterpiece that had already been appraised at nearly half a billion dollars in total value if both versions (the original and the one he owned) were considered. He spent approximately $90,000 on a meticulous restoration process. Conservators used specialized techniques to reweave the torn fibers and match the pigment, ensuring the repair was structurally sound and visually seamless to the naked eye under normal lighting. The process took several months and involved top-tier experts in fine art conservation.
Legal disputes and insurance
Wynn’s insurers, Lloyd’s of London, were involved in a legal dispute over the loss in value. Wynn argued that even a perfectly restored painting was worth less than an untouched one. The case highlighted the subjective nature of art valuation, where physical damage can have outsized financial and symbolic impacts. Although the specific settlement amount was not widely publicized, the incident underscored the complexities of insuring high-value, unique assets. It raised questions about whether a repaired object retains its original market status or becomes a different entity altogether.
The final sale price
Despite the accident and the intervening financial crisis, the painting’s value did not drop. In 2013, Steven A. Cohen purchased Le Rêve from Wynn for $155 million. This price was significantly higher than the $139 million previously agreed upon before the tear. The increase suggests that the story of the accident added to the painting’s narrative and provenance, making it a more compelling object of desire for collectors. The market treated the repair not as a defect, but as part of the artwork’s history.
Why the painting survived
Works from Picasso’s 1932 period are often physically delicate compared to earlier Old Master pieces. The oils and primers used at the time were experimental and less stable, making the canvas more prone to tearing than shattering. This flexibility allowed the damage to be contained to a specific area, facilitating a successful repair. The incident remains a cautionary tale for collectors about the fragility of art and the importance of proper handling, even among those with the resources to buy the most expensive works in the world.