When market dynamics shift, supply chains fracture, inflation surges, or project costs spiral out of control, a legally binding agreement that once promised profitability can quickly transform into a financial liability. Under IFRS, companies cannot simply wait for these losses to materialize on an invoice-by-invoice basis; instead, accounting standards mandate the immediate recognition of potential future losses.
This first part of our expert series dives deep into the architecture of onerous contracts under IFRS. We will explore the fundamental definitions, navigate the governing standards—principally IAS 37 Provisions, Contingent Liabilities and Contingent Assets, along with its intersections with IFRS 15 Revenue from Contracts with Customers and IFRS 16 Leases—and unpack the pivotal 2022 amendments that reshaped how organizations calculate the cost of fulfillment.
1. The core definition: What is an Onerous Contract?
At its simplest, an onerous contract is defined under IAS 37.10 as a contract in which the unavoidable costs of meeting the obligations under the contract exceed the economic benefits expected to be received under it.
To break down this definition into its core commercial components, two elements must be present:
A Legal Obligation: There must be an existing, binding contract that creates enforceable rights and obligations for both parties. A mere intention, unformalized negotiation, or non-binding memorandum of understanding does not qualify.
Economic Disadvantage: The lower bound of fulfilling the contract requires an outflow of resources that outweighs any inflows or utility derived from the agreement.
The asymmetry of Financial recognition
Traditional accrual accounting is built on matching revenues with expenses. However, onerous contracts represent an exception driven by the principle of prudence and the framework of loss recognition. Under standard accounting rules, if a company enters into a commercial arrangement where it is contractually obligated to deliver goods or services at a price lower than the cost of production, the resulting loss is not deferred until delivery.
Instead, the moment a contract is identified as onerous, IFRS requires the entity to recognize a provision for the present obligation. This accelerates the recognition of losses into the current reporting period, ensuring that financial statement users are not blindsided by hidden commitments that will drain future cash flows.
2. The Regulatory framework: Where does IFRS govern Onerous Contracts?
Accounting for onerous contracts does not live in a single vacuum; rather, it spans multiple IFRS standards depending on the nature of the underlying transaction. Understanding which standard applies is the first step toward accurate treatment.
IAS 37: Provisions, Contingent Liabilities and Contingent Assets
IAS 37 serves as the baseline standard for provisions in general. Paragraph 66 of IAS 37 states explicitly:
"If an entity has a contract that is onerous, the present obligation under the contract is recognized and measured as a provision."
However, IAS 37 operates with a major scope exclusion: it generally does not apply to contracts that are within the scope of other specific IFRS standards (such as IFRS 15 or IFRS 16), unless those specific standards explicitly direct the preparer back to IAS 37.
IFRS 15: Revenue from Contracts with Customers
For customer contracts, IFRS 15 governs revenue recognition, but it intersects directly with IAS 37 regarding onerous contracts. Under IFRS 15, an entity assesses whether a customer contract is onerous before transferring control of the goods or services.
If a specific customer contract is determined to be onerous, the entity applies IAS 37 to measure and recognize the resulting loss provision. This creates a seamless bridge between revenue accounting and liability recognition.
IFRS 16: Leases
Lease contracts present a common arena for onerous agreements, for instance, when a company leases commercial office space or retail storefronts that it no longer occupies or can sub-lease only at a steep discount.
Under IFRS 16, lessees recognize right-of-use (ROU) assets and lease liabilities. When a lease becomes onerous (often evaluated as part of an impairment test of the ROU asset), the principles of IAS 37 (or impairment rules under IAS 36 Impairment of Assets) guide how the carrying amount is written down and whether additional provisions are required.
3. The 2022 turning point: Understanding the Amendments to IAS 37
For years, a major point of divergence and ambiguity in financial reporting was how companies defined the "cost of fulfilling a contract" when assessing whether it was onerous.
Some entities argued that the cost of fulfillment should include only the incremental costs of fulfilling that specific contract (e.g., direct raw materials and direct labor).
Other entities maintained that the cost of fulfillment should also include an allocation of other costs directly related to contract activities (e.g., a systematic allocation of depreciation for manufacturing equipment used to execute the contract).
To resolve this inconsistency, the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) issued Onerous Contracts, Cost of Fulfilling a Contract (Amendments to IAS 37), which became effective for annual reporting periods beginning on or after January 1, 2022.
The "Cost of Fulfilling" Clarified
The 2022 amendments explicitly clarified that the cost of fulfilling a contract comprises the costs that relate directly to the contract. These directly related costs consist of both:
Incremental costs of fulfilling that contract: Costs that an entity incurs only because it entered into the contract (such as direct labor, direct materials, and commissions paid to sales agents).
An allocation of other costs that relate directly to fulfilling contracts: Costs that are not strictly incremental but are directly attributable to fulfilling contract activities (such as the allocation of depreciation charge for an item of property, plant, and equipment used in fulfilling that specific contract).
This clarification broadened the scope of what must be included in loss calculations, making it more difficult for companies to mask potential contract losses by excluding overhead and asset allocations that are tied to production.
4. Identifying an Onerous Contract: Indicators and triggers
Identifying whether a contract has crossed the threshold into "onerous" territory requires continuous monitoring of operational metrics, macroeconomic conditions, and contractual terms. Management must look for specific warning signs across their portfolio of obligations.
+-----------------------------------------------------------------+
| OPERATIONAL & MARKET TRIGGERS |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------+
| • Spiking raw material or energy costs exceeding pricing caps |
| • Unexpected labor shortages driving up overtime expenses |
| • Supply chain disruptions forcing expensive spot-market buying|
| • Regulatory shifts increasing compliance costs |
| • Unanticipated technical hurdles extending project timelines |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------+
│
▼
+-----------------------------------------------------------------+
| FINANCIAL ASSESSMENT |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------+
| Compare Unavoidable Costs vs. Expected Inflows |
| (Unavoidable Costs = Lower of Cost to Fulfill vs. Penalty) |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------+
│
▼
+-----------------------------------------------------------------+
| DETERMINATION & ACCOUNTING ACTION |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------+
| If Costs > Benefits ──► Recognize Onerous Provision (IAS 37) |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------+
Key triggers to watch for
Cost Inflation: In fixed-price long-term manufacturing or construction contracts, a sudden surge in commodity prices (e.g., steel, semiconductor chips, or fuel) can push the direct cost of delivery far above the agreed-upon contract price.
Labor Market Pressures: Escalating wage inflation or mandatory collective bargaining agreements can make service-level agreements unprofitable.
Operational Bottlenecks: Delays caused by internal inefficiencies or external forces can trigger contractual penalty clauses (liquidated damages) that rapidly erode project margins.
Currency Fluctuations: For contracts denominated in foreign currencies where hedging strategies are absent or ineffective, adverse exchange rate movements can flip a profitable transaction into a severe loss-maker.
5. Measuring the Obligation: The "Lower of" rule
Once an entity determines that a contract is onerous, it must measure the provision accurately. Under IAS 37.68, the measurement of the provision must reflect the least net cost of exiting from the contract, which is the lower of:
The cost of fulfilling the contract (incorporating both incremental costs and allocated direct overhead costs as mandated by the 2022 amendments); and
Any compensation or penalties arising from failure to fulfill the contract (the termination or default cost).
This rule forces management to perform a comparative cost-benefit analysis. If it is cheaper for a company to pay a financial penalty to break a contract than to continue fulfilling it at an ongoing operational loss, the provision is measured based on the termination penalty. Conversely, if terminating the contract carries reputational, legal, or financial penalties that exceed the operating losses of fulfillment, the entity must measure the provision based on the total remaining costs required to complete the contractual obligations.
Measuring the Onerous Contract Provision: The "Lower net Cost" principle
Once an entity has established that a contract falls within the scope of IAS 37 and meets the strict definition of being onerous, the next critical hurdle is measurement. Under IAS 37.68, the provision must be measured at the present value of the lower of:
The cost of fulfilling the contract, and
Any compensation or penalties arising from failure to fulfill it.
This principle ensures that management acts economically. If it is cheaper for an entity to break a contract and pay a termination penalty than it is to continue performing under its terms, the provision is measured based on the penalty. Conversely, if terminating the contract incurs exorbitant legal fees or reputational damage that exceeds the loss from fulfillment, the entity must measure the provision based on the unavoidable costs of fulfilling the obligations.
Determining the Cost of fulfillment
The cost of fulfilling a contract comprises the unavoidable costs relating directly to the contract. Under the amendments to IAS 37 (effective January 1, 2022), these costs include both:
Incremental costs of fulfilling that contract (e.g., direct labor, direct materials, and subcontractor fees).
An allocation of other costs that relate directly to fulfilling contracts (e.g., an allocated share of depreciation of equipment used to fulfill that contract).
General and administrative overheads that do not relate directly to fulfilling the contract (such as general corporate management salaries or headquarters rent) are strictly excluded unless they are explicitly chargeable to the counterparty under the contract terms.
Accounting treatment and journal entries
Recognizing an onerous contract requires an immediate recognition of a provision and a corresponding charge to profit or loss.
Initial Recognition
When the onerous nature of the contract is first identified, the entity records the following entry:
Debit: Profit or Loss (Operating Expense – Provision for Onerous Contracts)
Credit: Provision for Onerous Contracts (Statement of Financial Position / Liability)
This upfront recognition often creates a significant earnings dip in the period the contract becomes onerous, reflecting future expected losses before they are physically cash-settled. This aligns with the accrual accounting principle and the overarching framework of prudence under IFRS.
Subsequent Measurement
Provisions cannot remain static. Under IAS 37.59, entities must review provisions at the end of each reporting period and adjust them to reflect the current best estimate.
If costs increase further: The provision is increased, with the additional expense recognized immediately in profit or loss.
If conditions improve (Reversal): If the economic environment shifts, supply chain costs drop, or expected revenues increase such that the contract is no longer onerous, the provision must be reversed. The reversal is credited back to profit or loss, reducing the liability. However, the carrying amount of the provision can only be reduced to zero; it cannot create a negative liability or premature revenue recognition.
Sector-Specific applications and interplay with other IFRS Standards
Onerous contracts manifest differently across industries, often requiring careful navigation between IAS 37 and other specific IFRS standards.
1. Construction and Engineering (IFRS 15)
For long-term construction or service contracts accounted for under IFRS 15 (Revenue from Contracts with Customers), expected losses on a contract are recognized under IAS 37. If a performance obligation is satisfied over time and total estimated contract costs exceed total contract revenue, the entire expected loss is recognized immediately as an expense, rather than being deferred across future reporting periods.
2. Leases (IFRS 16)
Before IFRS 16, operating lease contracts that became unprofitable were accounted for as onerous contracts under IAS 37. Under the current lease standard (IFRS 16), almost all leases are brought onto the balance sheet as a right-of-use (ROU) asset and a lease liability. Consequently, potential onerous lease contracts are first tested for impairment under IAS 36 (Impairment of Assets) by assessing the recoverable amount of the ROU asset. Only if the ROU asset is written down to zero does an entity recognize an additional provision under IAS 37 for any remaining unavoidable lease payments.
3. Manufacturing and Supply chain agreements
Fixed-price supply agreements exposed to severe commodity price inflation or supply chain shocks frequently turn onerous. If raw material prices spike to a point where the selling price fixed in the customer contract fails to cover direct production and allocation costs, a provision must be recorded immediately for all remaining deliveries under the binding agreement.
Key disclosures and Financial Statement impact
Transparency is paramount when dealing with provisions, as they involve a high degree of management estimation and judgment. Under IAS 37.84–85, entities must provide a reconciliation for each class of provision, showing:
The opening balance.
Additional provisions made in the period, including increases to existing provisions.
Amounts used (incurred and charged against the provision) during the period.
Unused amounts reversed during the period.
The increase during the period in the discounted amount arising from the passage of time (the unwinding of the discount).
The notes to the financial statements must disclose:
A brief description of the nature of the obligation and the expected timing of any resulting outflows of economic benefits.
An indication of the uncertainties about the amount or timing of those outflows. Where necessary, entities must disclose the major assumptions made concerning future events.
The amount of any expected reimbursement, stating the amount of any asset that has been recognized for that expected reimbursement.
Common audit pitfalls and challenges
Navigating onerous contract assessments presents several recurring challenges for financial controllers and auditors alike:
Lagging Identification: Management frequently delays recognizing onerous contracts, hoping that market conditions will self-correct before the next reporting date. Auditors scrutinize gross margin forecasts and budget variances to catch deteriorating contracts early.
Inappropriate Cost Allocations: Including general overheads improperly inflates the provision, whereas excluding direct operational allocations understates it. Determining the exact boundary of "costs that relate directly to the contract" requires rigorous cost-accounting rigor.
Failure to Consider Penalty Clauses: Forgetting to evaluate the cancellation penalty route can lead to overstating provisions if walking away from the contract is legally viable and financially more prudent.
Conclusion
Onerous contracts serve as a vital stress-test for an entity's financial reporting integrity. By enforcing the immediate recognition of unavoidable future losses, IFRS ensures that financial statements do not mask underlying operational failures or mask the true financial health of the business. For finance professionals, mastering the interplay between IAS 37, IFRS 15, and IFRS 16 is essential not only for regulatory compliance but for safeguarding stakeholder trust in an unpredictable economic landscape.
