Why doesn't FIFA 23 have Brazil? Unpacking the complex World of video game licensing (part 1)
This isn't just a minor oversight or a simple programming error by a multi-billion-dollar developer. Rather, it represents the tip of a massive, deeply complex iceberg known in the gaming and sports industries as digital licensing. To understand why one of the most successful and culturally significant football nations on Earth is routinely missing from the world’s most popular football franchise, one must journey far beyond the pitch. The absence of Brazil in FIFA 23 is a masterclass in bureaucratic red tape, unique legal protections, aggressive corporate rivalries, and the multi-layered economics of sports media rights.
The illusion of universal access: How Football licensing actually works
To the average fan, it is easy to assume that making a modern sports video game is simply a matter of coding gameplay mechanics, designing stadiums, and plugging in real-world rosters. After all, football is a global sport governed by centralized bodies. Surely, if a game developer secures a partnership with FIFA (the Fédération Internationale de Football Association) or various continental confederations, they automatically gain the rights to use every country, club, and player on the planet, right?
In reality, the ecosystem of football licensing is remarkably decentralized and fractured. EA Sports does not possess a magical, all-encompassing master key that unlocks every single football asset in existence. Instead, the developers must piece together hundreds of individual licensing agreements like a colossal, high-stakes jigsaw puzzle.
The Governing Bodies: Partnerships with organizations like UEFA or CONMEBOL grant rights to specific tournaments (such as the Champions League or Copa Libertadores), but these do not automatically grant blanket ownership over individual member federations.
The National Associations: Each country’s football federation (such as the Brazilian Football Confederation, or CBF) operates as an independent entity with its own commercial rights, legal representation, and financial expectations.
The Players' Unions and FIFPRO: FIFPro represents thousands of professional players globally, allowing developers to feature real player likenesses en masse. However, regional exceptions and individual opt-outs frequently complicate these agreements.
Individual Clubs: Domestic leagues require separate negotiations with individual clubs or collective league bodies, each demanding compensation that aligns with their commercial valuation.
When a powerhouse like Brazil goes missing from standard game modes, it means that one or more pieces of this massive legal puzzle fundamentally broke down during negotiations.
The Brazilian legal labyrinth: Image rights and the "Pelé Law"
At the heart of the issue regarding Brazil's exclusion from FIFA 23 lies a unique legal framework governing professional sports and personal image rights within the country itself. Unlike many European nations where a player's collective image rights can often be negotiated cleanly through national unions, leagues, or federations, Brazil enforces stringent individual protections.
Historically shaped by specific legislation, frequently referred to by sports lawyers and analysts through historical frameworks like the Pelé Law (Lei Pelé), Brazilian civil framework strictly dictates that an athlete's image, name, and likeness belong exclusively to the individual. They cannot be bartered away wholesale by a third-party collective, a club, or even a national football confederation without explicit, individual consent and financial compensation.
For a video game developer like EA Sports, this creates a monumental logistical nightmare. To feature the Brazilian national team authentically in a standard game build, the studio cannot simply sign a single lucrative contract with the CBF. Doing so only secures the rights to the federation's name and crest, but it does not legally clear the rights to use the actual human beings wearing the jersey.
Consequently, EA Sports would theoretically be forced to track down, negotiate with, and compensate dozens, if not hundreds, of individual Brazilian players and their respective legal representatives across the globe. Because many of these players are scattered across elite European leagues, domestic Brazilian clubs, and various international tiers, executing individual contracts for every single roster iteration becomes an economically unviable hurdle. Weighing the immense legal expenses and administrative friction against projected profits, developers have repeatedly chosen to omit the official licensing rather than court potential multi-million-dollar lawsuits in Brazilian courts.
Navigating the legal labyrinth: Image rights, Brazilian labor Law, and the path forward
The constitutional hurdle of image rights in Brazil
To fully grasp why the Seleção and domestic Brazilian clubs have historically presented such a persistent roadblock for developers, one must look beyond standard corporate video game licensing agreements and examine Brazilian civil and constitutional law.
Unlike many European and North American jurisdictions, where collective bargaining agreements or union-level frameworks (such as FIFPRO) can comprehensively license groups of player likenesses en masse, Brazilian law treats a person's image rights (direito de imagem) as an unalienable, fiercely protected personal asset. Under Article 5 of the Brazilian Federal Constitution and specific provisions within Brazil's Pelé Law (Lei Pelé), an athlete's image, name, and biographical likeness cannot be commercially exploited by a third party through collective assignment alone, unless individual, direct authorization or a specific private contractual sub-licensing fee is secured.
For a global publisher like Electronic Arts, this structural legal reality turns what should be a straightforward administrative transaction into an unfeasible logistical challenge:
The Collective Bargaining Gap: While global bodies represent broad player interests, they have historically lacked the legal mandate under Brazilian jurisprudence to sign away individual athlete image rights for digital software.
Individual Negotiations: To feature a fully licensed Brazilian league or national team squad with real player names, EA would theoretically be forced to negotiate hundreds, if not thousands, of independent contracts with individual players, their legal representatives, and respective clubs.
Historical Litigation: Past attempts to lean on umbrella agreements resulted in high-profile individual lawsuits from Brazilian players and athletes claiming unauthorized commercial exploitation of their likenesses, forcing publishers to scrub authentic rosters entirely to mitigate crippling legal liability.
The Tug-of-War: Exclusive partnerships and market competition
Adding fuel to the fire, the commercial landscape of football video game franchises has long been defined by fierce rivalry and strategic exclusivity. For years, competing publishers recognized the immense value of the Brazilian football market, the second-largest gaming demographic globally, and moved swiftly to lock down localized partnerships.
Concurrently, negotiations with the Brazilian Football Confederation (CBF) involved separate, fluctuating valuations for national team licensing versus domestic club competitions. When exclusivity clauses or financial demands escalated past what EA’s annual budget allocated for regional markets lacking unified player-rights solutions, compromises collapsed. Consequently, fans witnessed years where domestic Brazilian teams featured entirely generic squads populated by placeholder names, while the national team vanished entirely from standard exhibition and career modes outside of special tournament patches.
Alternative solutions and community workarounds
During periods where official licensing agreements stalled, such as during the lifecycle of FIFA 23, the gaming community developed creative methods to bridge the authenticity gap:
The World Cup Mode Exception: In rare instances like the late-2022 tournament update, separate overarching event licenses secured directly through FIFA momentarily bypassed routine domestic gridlocks, permitting the inclusion of authentic national squads for specific tournament windows.
Squad Customization and Editor Tools: Dedicated players spent countless hours manually editing player attributes, tactical setups, and kit appearances in-game to recreate the missing squads from scratch.
Modding Culture: On platforms supporting modifications, PC players routinely injected fan-made asset packages containing real faces, authentic kits, and accurate rosters to restore the missing South American giants to their rightful place.
A Transforming Horizon
The complex absence of Brazil from titles like FIFA 23 serves as a textbook study in the friction between global software development and localized legal sovereignty. As regulatory frameworks evolve and digital rights management matures within South America, the pathways for international sports simulations are slowly shifting. Landmark agreements and evolving partnerships signal that the future of virtual football licensing is gradually adapting to bridge the gap between passionate fanbases and complex jurisdictional realities.
