YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE
ASSOCIATED TAGS
achilles  achilles'  affection  ancient  briseis  classical  devotion  emotional  expressed  heroic  homeric  language  modern  patroclus  philosophical  
LATEST POSTS

What did Achilles say about love?

What did Achilles say about love?

The anatomy of heroic passion: Exploring Achilles and the language of Love

To understand what Achilles expressed about love—both through his direct words in the ancient epic and through his earth-shattering actions—we must first step outside of modern frameworks and immerse ourselves in the brutal, beautiful reality of the heroic age. This first part of our exploration examines the textual foundations of Achilles’ devotion, the nature of his bond with Patroclus, and how the concept of love in the Iliad is inextricably linked with mortality, identity, and choice.

The silence of the epic and the weight of action

One of the most fascinating aspects of Homeric poetry is how restraint shapes emotional intensity. Unlike later classical Greek literature, where authors like Plato and Aeschylus openly debated the romantic nature of Achilles and Patroclus’ relationship, Homer’s text leaves room for profound interpretation by focusing relentlessly on consequences rather than labels. Achilles never sits down to deliver a neat, philosophical treatise defining what love is. Instead, his understanding of love is revealed entirely through crisis.

In the world of the Iliad, love is measured by what a person is willing to sacrifice. For Achilles, who possesses the divine knowledge that his life will be short and brilliantly glorious (kleos), his primary emotional anchor is Patroclus, a companion raised alongside him in Phthia after being exiled for a childhood manslaughter. When Achilles speaks of Patroclus, or when he reacts to his loss, his language breaks away from standard military camaraderie. He describes a depth of attachment that renders all other concerns, even his fierce pride and his bitter feud with Agamemnon, utterly meaningless.

Consider the sheer magnitude of Achilles’ reaction upon learning of Patroclus' death at the hands of Hector. The hero who refused to fight to preserve his own honor suddenly finds his honor worthless. He pours ash over his head, tears at his hair, and embraces the corpse with a desperation that transcends conventional mourning. The love Achilles demonstrates is totalizing; it consumes his identity, transforming him from a sulking petitioner into an engine of pure vengeance.

"Ah me, is it true, even in the house of Hades, a spirit and phantom still, though the breath be gone from it?", The Iliad, Book 23

Even in death, Achilles seeks to defy the boundaries separating him from the person he loves, demanding that their bones be mingled together in a single golden urn so that they may never be separated. If love in the heroic age has a definition, it is this: an absolute refusal to accept permanent division, even by death.

The dual faces of desire: Briseis and Patroclus

To fully grasp Achilles' relationship with the concept of love, we must also examine his interactions with Briseis, the captive woman whose seizure by Agamemnon sparks the central conflict of the epic. Modern retellings, such as Madeline Miller’s acclaimed novel The Song of Achilles, vividly dramatize the emotional architecture of the hero's life, but even within the traditional framework of the Iliad, Achilles' capacity for deep emotional attachment extends across multiple dimensions.

With Briseis, Achilles displays a tender protectiveness and genuine grief when she is torn from his tent. Yet, his relationship with Briseis exists within the transactional social structures of the Bronze Age, she is a prize of honor (giras) that symbolizes his status among the Achaeans. When she is taken, the injury is primarily to his public standing and his emotional core alike.

In contrast, his bond with Patroclus operates outside the hierarchy of war loot and societal status. Patroclus is his therapon, a word often translated as squire or attendant, but which carries a weight closer to "comrade-in-arms" or "second self." When Patroclus is alive, he is the only person who can temper Achilles' rage, gently pulling him back from the precipice of his own pride. When Patroclus dies, that stabilizing force vanishes, leaving Achilles completely untethered.

Through these dynamics, the epic suggests that Achilles views love through two distinct lenses:

  • The Love of Companionship and Equality: A transcendent, soul-deep bond that defies ordinary social rules and drives the hero to court his own doom.

  • The Love of Affection and Stewardship: A protective, deeply human care demonstrated toward those within his household and inner circle.

The choice: Short life, immortal Love

At the core of Achilles' character is a profound existential dilemma presented to him by his divine mother, Thetis: he can choose a long, quiet, ordinary life in Phthia and be forgotten by history, or he can choose a short, brilliant life at Troy, winning imperishable glory (kleos) at the cost of an early death.

When Patroclus dies, Achilles realizes the true price of his choice. The glory he pursued loses its luster because there is no one left to share it with, no one to witness the songs that will be sung about him. In his grief, his perspective on what matters shifts dramatically. He recognizes that honor, prizes, and the praise of kings are hollow substitutes for genuine human connection.

By choosing to re-enter the battle knowing full well that his own death will immediately follow the slaying of Hector, Achilles makes a statement about love that echoes across millennia. He chooses a condensed, burning eternity alongside the memory of his closest companion rather than decades of hollow survival.

Transition to part two

As we continue this exploration in the subsequent section, we will delve deeper into the philosophical and cultural interpretations of Achilles' words. We will analyze how ancient writers viewed the intersection of martial prowess and emotional vulnerability, how later generations reinterpreted the "language of the heart" found in Homeric verse, and what lessons this timeless archetype holds for modern understandings of devotion, grief, and the human condition.

The epic legacy: What Achilles said and taught about Love

While Homer’s Iliad is fundamentally framed as a song of destructive anger, opening with the famous invocation of rage (menên), it ultimately evolves into one of Western literature's most profound explorations of love, grief, and human devotion. When exploring what Achilles said about love, readers must look beyond modern definitions of romantic speech. In the Bronze Age heroic framework of Homeric epic, love was not articulated through abstract philosophical declarations or sentimental declarations. Instead, Achilles expressed love through absolute valuation, raw grief, and choices that defied mortality itself.

The architecture of Homeric devotion: Actions speak louder than words

In the text of the Iliad, Achilles never delivers a neat, modern soliloquy defining love. Homer does not script romantic monologues for his central figures; instead, he constructs love through consequence. When Patroclus dies, Achilles’ response transcends standard mourning:

"He falls in the dust and tears at his own hair; the servant women scream... His mother Thetis hears the cry from the floor of the sea..."

Achilles’ declaration of what Patroclus meant to him is written in his rejection of life, honor, and safety. He explicitly states that his companion is valued above all others, equal to his own soul. When speaking of the future, Achilles wishes for a world stripped away of all other Greek and Trojan lives so that only the two of them might remain to sack the city. While ancient commentators like Aristarchus debated the sheer intensity of this passage, it remains Achilles’ ultimate poetic statement on companionship: an absolute prioritization of the beloved over the entire external world.

The Classical reinterpretation: Plato and the Symposium

Centuries after Homer, Classical Athenians re-evaluated the silence of the Iliad. In Plato’s Symposium, speakers actively debate the nature of the bond between Achilles and Patroclus, turning the hero into an archetype of passionate love (eros).

Phaedrus argues in the Symposium that Achilles was the younger beloved (eromenos) who deliberately chose to die to avenge and honor his lover (erastes) Patroclus:

  • The Ultimate Sacrifice: Plato presents Achilles' return to battle, knowing full well it seals his doom, as the supreme act of devotion.

  • Rewarding Love: According to classical philosophical tradition, the gods honored Achilles uniquely because he placed his affection above self-preservation, granting him a place in the Isles of the Blessed.

Modern echoes and cultural resonance

The silence of the ancient text has allowed modern literature to imagine the words Achilles might have spoken if he possessed a modern vocabulary for devotion. Madeline Miller’s acclaimed contemporary novel, The Song of Achilles, brilliantly captures the emotional weight of their bond through iconic lines that mirror the depth of the Homeric tradition:

"I could recognize him by touch alone, by smell; I would know him blind, by the way his breaths came and his feet struck the earth. I would know him in death, at the end of the world."

Though crafted in the 21st century, such sentiments capture the internal landscape that Homer left unwritten. Achilles’ true "words" on love were his actions: the abandonment of his wrath against Agamemnon, the embrace of a shortened life, and the request that their bones be forever mingled together in a single golden urn.

Love as a fatal force

What Achilles teaches us about love is that it is coextensive with mortality. In the heroic world, to love deeply is to expose oneself to unbearable loss. Achilles did not offer poetic aphorisms about affection; he demonstrated that love is a force powerful enough to break the constraints of fate, outvalue divine immortality, and render death itself a secondary concern compared to the agony of separation.