VFA in IFRS 17 refers to the Variable Fee Approach, a specialized method for measuring certain insurance contracts where policyholders absorb the financial impact of investment performance. Instead of the insurer recognizing profit upfront, earnings emerge as returns on underlying assets are realized, reflecting the economic reality of these arrangements.
When does the Variable Fee Approach apply?
The VFA is not the default model. It only applies to insurance contracts that meet three strict criteria. First, the contract must have a direct participating feature, meaning policyholders receive a clear share of returns from specific underlying items like bonds or equities. Second, the insurer must not have significant exposure to the risks and rewards of those underlying items—it acts as an intermediary. Third, the amount returned to policyholders must vary directly with the performance of those investments.
These conditions exclude many traditional with-profits or bonus-paying policies where returns are smoothed or discretion is broad. Only contracts with transparent, measurable links between asset performance and policyholder benefits qualify. If any condition is unmet, the contract falls under the general model.
How profit is recognized under VFA
Under the Variable Fee Approach, profit recognition is delayed until investment returns are earned. Unlike traditional accounting, where insurers might book margins at inception, VFA defers profit. The insurer earns a variable fee—its share of the returns, over time as the underlying assets perform.
The contractual service margin (CSM) captures unearned profit. As investment returns materialize, the CSM is adjusted. If actual returns exceed expectations, the CSM increases, and more profit can be released. If returns are lower, the CSM may decrease. This adjustment reflects the insurer’s share of the surplus or deficit, with the rest allocated to policyholders as a liability.
Discounting and risk adjustments in VFA
One key difference between VFA and the general model is the treatment of investment risk. Since policyholders bear investment risk, the discount rate used in VFA excludes compensation for that risk. The rate reflects only the time value of money and liquidity characteristics of the liability.
Likewise, no risk adjustment is required for investment volatility. However, insurers must still account for non-financial risks such as mortality, lapses, and expenses. These are included in the risk adjustment and affect the measurement of fulfilment cash flows. This streamlined approach reduces complexity but increases earnings volatility, as profits move with market performance.
VFA versus the general model
The general model is the default under IFRS 17 and applies to most insurance contracts. It allows insurers to lock in discount rates and smooth returns over time, leading to more stable reported earnings. It also includes both financial and non-financial risks in the risk adjustment, giving more room for judgment in cash flow estimates.
In contrast, VFA offers greater transparency but less stability. Profit recognition closely follows asset performance, so results can swing with markets. While this reflects economic substance more accurately, it can make financial reporting more volatile. Insurers with qualifying contracts often separate them into VFA portfolios, while the rest remain under the general model.