YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE
ASSOCIATED TAGS
beaver  bronze  campus  football  institutional  monument  outside  paterno  physical  public  remains  sandusky  stadium  statue  university  
LATEST POSTS

Is the Joe Paterno statue still up at Penn State?

Is the Joe Paterno statue still up at Penn State?

To understand the absence of the statue today, one must examine both its current physical disposition and the intense cultural, institutional, and moral reckoning that transformed a symbol of athletic excellence into a lightning rod for national outrage. While the monument itself remains hidden from public view in a secure university storage facility, the debate over its removal, its potential return, and the broader legacy of the Paterno era continues to reverberate through State College, Pennsylvania, and across the landscape of American collegiate athletics.

The current status and location of the Monument

For visitors arriving at University Park for a Nittany Lions football game, the absence of the statue is immediately noticeable to anyone familiar with the campus prior to 2012. For eleven years, the area outside Beaver Stadium served as a pilgrimage site for fans, alumni, and recruits, who routinely posed for photographs beneath the raised index finger of the legendary coach. Following its removal, the university swiftly reconfigured the footprint of the plaza. The granite wall that bore the inscription "Educator, Coach, Humanitarian" was dismantled, and the walkway was repaved to erase the physical outline of the shrine. Today, there is no plaque, marker, or memorial indicating where the statue once stood.

As for the bronze sculpture itself, Penn State officials have consistently stated that the statue is being held in a secure, undisclosed storage location on campus. Despite persistent rumors over the years, ranging from claims that it was melted down to speculation that it was privately transferred to the Paterno family, the university has maintained ownership of the piece, which was originally funded by private donations through the Penn State Letterman’s Club.

In the years since 2012, multiple university presidents, including Eric Barron and Neeli Bendapudi, as well as the Penn State Board of Trustees, have faced recurring questions regarding whether the statue might ever be reinstalled, either at Beaver Stadium or inside a campus museum contextualizing the history of Penn State football. The institutional stance has remained resolute: there are no plans to return the statue to public display. The prevailing consensus among university leadership is that reinstalling the monument would reopen deep wounds, alienate survivors of child sexual abuse, and signal a regression in the institution's commitment to accountability and cultural reform.

The Creation of an Icon: 2001 to 2011

To appreciate the magnitude of the statue's removal, it is necessary to understand what it represented when it was unveiled on November 2, 2001. At the time, Joe Paterno was in his 36th season as head coach and had recently surpassed Paul "Bear" Bryant to become the winningest coach in major college football history, a milestone he achieved on October 27, 2001, with a victory over Ohio State.

Commissioned by the Penn State Letterman’s Club and sculpted by Angelo DiBona, the bronze statue depicted Paterno mid-stride, wearing his signature thick-rimmed glasses, rolled-up khakis, and windbreaker, with his right index finger raised toward the sky in a gesture symbolizing both a #1 ranking and the pursuit of excellence. The monument was intentionally placed at ground level rather than atop a high pedestal, a design choice meant to reflect Paterno’s accessibility, humility, and connection to the everyday student and fan.

During this era, Paterno was widely regarded not merely as a football coach, but as the moral compass of Pennsylvania State University. He and his wife, Sue, had donated millions of dollars to the university, most notably funding the expansion of the Pattee Library, which was subsequently named the Paterno Library. In an era when college athletics was increasingly marred by academic fraud, booster scandals, and coaching mercenaries, Paterno’s "Grand Experiment", the philosophy that athletes could succeed at the highest level of Division I competition while maintaining genuine academic integrity, made him a folk hero. The statue outside Beaver Stadium was the physical embodiment of that ethos, casting in bronze the belief that Penn State was fundamentally different from, and morally superior to, its peers.

The collapse of a legacy and the Freeh Report

That carefully constructed image began to unravel in November 2011, when former Penn State defensive coordinator Jerry Sandusky was arrested and charged with multiple counts of child sexual abuse spanning more than a decade, including assaults committed inside university football facilities. Within days of Sandusky’s arrest, the Penn State Board of Trustees fired Paterno via a late-night phone call, concluding that while he had fulfilled his legal obligation by reporting a 2001 incident to athletic director Tim Curley, he had failed in his moral responsibility to protect children and ensure the matter was properly investigated. Paterno died of lung cancer just two months later, on January 22, 2012, at the age of 85.

In the immediate aftermath of his death, the statue outside Beaver Stadium became a makeshift memorial, surrounded by flowers, candles, handwritten notes, and blue-and-white ribbons. For many alumni and local residents, the monument stood as a symbol of defiance against what they viewed as a rushed and unfair judgment by the Board of Trustees and the national media.

That dynamic shifted dramatically on July 12, 2012, with the release of the Freeh Report. Conducted by former FBI Director Louis Freeh at the behest of the Board of Trustees, the 267-page investigation concluded that Paterno, along with university president Graham Spanier, athletic director Tim Curley, and senior vice president Gary Schultz, had actively concealed Sandusky’s abuse from the public and law enforcement to avoid negative publicity for the university and its football program. While the Paterno family and many supporters vigorously disputed the report’s methodology and conclusions, the document triggered a wave of institutional and public condemnation.

Within ten days of the report's release, pressure mounted exponentially. Protests erupted on campus, calls grew louder for the university to sever all symbolic ties to the Paterno era, and the NCAA prepared to levy unprecedented sanctions against the football program. On the morning of Sunday, July 22, 2012, university crews erected a blue tarp and chain-link fencing around the plaza. Using a forklift and heavy machinery, workers unbolted the bronze figure from its base, loaded it onto a flatbed truck, and transported it away from Beaver Stadium as a small crowd of onlookers watched in stunned silence. In an official statement released that morning, then-President Rodney Erickson explained that the statue had become "a source of division and an obstacle to healing in our university and beyond."

Once the bronze likeness of Joe Paterno was unbolted from its pedestal and hauled into storage on July 22, 2012, the physical space outside Beaver Stadium underwent an immediate and deliberate transformation. Rather than leaving an empty concrete plinth, which university officials feared would become a permanent shrine for protesters, vigils, or vandalism, Penn State moved swiftly to erase the architectural footprint of the monument. Within days, crews dismantled the semicircular stone wall that had framed the statue, leveled the raised dais, and laid fresh sod over the site. By the time the Nittany Lions kicked off their 2012 season, the corner of Curtain Road and Porter Road looked as though the seven-foot, 900-pound sculpture had never stood there at all.

The disappearance of the monument, however, did not settle the question of its fate; instead, it ignited a protracted battle over institutional memory, donor influence, and the limits of historical rehabilitation. For more than a decade, the statue has remained locked away in an undisclosed, climate-controlled university storage facility, effectively held in a state of administrative purgatory. While the bronze figure itself is out of public view, the debate surrounding it has flared repeatedly across campus, in boardrooms, and in Pennsylvania politics.

The architecture of absence and Campus geography

To understand why the absence of the statue remains so palpable in State College, one must look at the geography of Penn State’s athletic complex. The original monument was positioned directly outside the southeast corner of Beaver Stadium, along the path where the team buses arrived and thousands of tailgaters converged on autumn Saturdays. Sculpted by Angelo Di Maria and dedicated in 2001 to commemorate Paterno’s 324th victory, surpassing Bear Bryant’s major-college record, the statue depicted Paterno mid-stride, index finger raised toward the sky in his signature "We Are" gesture.

Following the release of the Freeh Report in July 2012, which concluded that Paterno and senior university administrators had concealed child sexual abuse allegations against former defensive coordinator Jerry Sandusky to avoid bad publicity, then-President Rodney Erickson ordered the statue’s removal. Erickson argued that the monument had become "a source of division and an obstacle to healing" for the university community and the survivors of Sandusky’s abuse.

In the years immediately following the removal, Penn State sought to redefine the public spaces around the stadium without erasing the broader history of its football program. The university opted against installing a replacement statue of another coach or player, recognizing that any singular figure would invite direct comparison to Paterno. Instead, campus planners leaned into collective iconography, expanding the presence of the Nittany Lion Shrine imagery, focusing on team-wide championship plaques, and redirecting fan rituals away from the former statue site. Yet for many alumni who return to Happy Valley each fall, the patch of grass outside Gate B remains an unofficial landmark, frequently pointed out to younger generations as the place where "Joe used to stand."

The "Success with Honor" plinth and the battle over words

While the statue itself vanished overnight, a crucial piece of the original installation lingered in a state of quiet controversy: the stone wall bearing the words "Success With Honor." Originally inscribed behind the statue to encapsulate Paterno’s stated philosophy of balancing athletic excellence with academic integrity and ethical conduct, the phrase had been adopted by Penn State for decades as an unofficial institutional motto.

When crews demolished the wall in July 2012, the engraved stone blocks were placed in storage alongside the bronze figure. For years, factions within the Penn State Board of Trustees, particularly alumni-elected trustees who ran on platforms critical of the university’s handling of the Sandusky scandal and the Freeh Report, lobbied to have the statue restored, or at least relocated to a museum or the Penn State All-Sports Museum inside Beaver Stadium.

By the late 2010s and early 2020s, as legal battles over the NCAA sanctions subsided and the university restored Paterno’s 111 vacated wins in 2015, calls to bring back the monument gained renewed momentum among vocal segments of the lettermen’s club and older boosters. However, university leadership consistently resisted full restoration, aware of the profound reputational damage and backlash from child advocacy groups that would follow any move to re-erect a public monument to Paterno.

A compromise of sorts emerged around the legacy of the program rather than the likeness of the coach. In 2021, Penn State announced plans to create a permanent display inside the All-Sports Museum honoring the 1982 and 1986 national championship teams, squads coached by Paterno, while keeping the statue itself in storage. Even this step drew sharp scrutiny, illustrating the razor-thin margin university administrators must walk between acknowledging athletic history and appearing to minimize institutional failures.

Why the statue remains in storage

More than fourteen years after its removal, the Joe Paterno statue is still not up at Penn State, and there are no official plans to display it publicly again. Several interlocking factors keep the monument behind locked doors:

  • Institutional Liability and Governance: Successive Penn State presidents, from Rodney Erickson to Eric Barron and Neeli Bendapudi, have prioritized institutional stability and survivor advocacy over nostalgic appeasement. Reinstalling the statue would immediately reopen settled public-relations wounds and alienate corporate sponsors, academic partners, and state lawmakers.

  • The Shift in Campus Demographics: The student body at Penn State today has no lived memory of the Paterno era. Born in the mid-to-late 2000s, current undergraduates grew up in a post-Sandusky world where Paterno is viewed primarily through the lens of a cautionary historical scandal rather than as a beloved campus patriarch. Without student demand, the push for restoration remains confined largely to aging alumni blocs.

  • The Precedent of Modern Monument Removals: Across American higher education and public life over the past decade, universities have increasingly removed statues of controversial historical figures rather than re-erecting them. Once a monument is taken down over ethical or moral failures, institutional inertia heavily favors keeping it out of public spaces.

  • The Custody Dilemma: Because the statue was funded by private donors, specifically the Paterno family’s friends and boosters, Penn State faces delicate legal and diplomatic questions regarding what to do with the physical bronze. Destroying or melting down the sculpture would provoke fierce outrage from major athletic donors, while gifting it to a private third party risks seeing it erected just off campus in downtown State College, creating a permanent visual confrontation at the university’s doorstep.

A permanent fixture of memory, not bronze

The status of the Joe Paterno statue serves as a physical barometer for Penn State’s ongoing reckoning with its past. The university has largely moved on from the punitive aftermath of the scandal, rebuilding its football program into a perennial College Football Playoff contender, restoring its statistical record books, and overhauling its compliance and youth-protection frameworks. Yet the bronze statue remains locked away precisely because a monument is fundamentally different from a record book.

Statistics record what happened on the field; a statue confers unambiguous moral reverence. By keeping the sculpture in storage while leaving the corner outside Beaver Stadium as an unmarked expanse of grass, Penn State has settled on an unspoken policy of containment. Joe Paterno’s name remains attached to the campus library, a naming right secured by millions of dollars in charitable fundraising prior to 2011, and his coaching records stand intact in the media guide. His likeness, however, stays out of sight, a silent acknowledgment that at Penn State, some chapters of history can be archived, even if they can never again be put on a pedestal.